Sexing and ageing is important for the identification of redpolls. Further identification will be easier when keeping these in mind. With redpolls, sexing and ageing isn’t always that simple. In the field it’s sometimes impossible. Shall we give it a go?
On the basis of the photos and captions below, I’ll try to explain sexing and age determination in simple language (otherwise not even I would understand it). First I'll make a distinction between three age categories:
From nest until the first moult (first calendar year). In reality it's a very short period of time.
After the first moult in Autumn (first calendar) until the second moult one year later (second calendar). So it’s exactly a period of time of one year.
From the second moult in Autumn (second calendar) onwards.
Let’s start simple with an adult male. An adult male means a redpoll that has moulted at least two times and can easily be identified by the pink colour (such as both arctic redpolls) or red colour (like the ‘common’ redpolls) of the feathers on the breast. Also the ear-coverts, the rump and the tail have red/pink tints. The amount of the red/pink colours varies from bird to bird. As the breeding season progresses, the red/pink colour intensifies (by feather wear). In the case of a male Greenland Redpoll (rostrata) the red/pink colour on the breast is almost absent.
An adult male is less streaked on its flanks and breast than a female or an immature bird.
Also a distinctive feature of male redpolls is the fact that these birds sing. Keep in mind that also second calendar year males (redpolls which are born the year before) sing.
Besides that, only the males ‘feed’ the females; the second calendar year males also like to feed the females to impress them.
Mealy Redpoll, adult male, Northern Finland, March, 2015. Red tints on the breast, tail and rump.
Coues’s Arctic Redpoll, adult male, Nothern Finland, March, 2015. Pink tints on the breast.
An adult female redpoll doesn’t have the red/pink tints on the breast, rump and/or tail, but she always has a red forecrown. Adult females sometimes have a little red/pink colour on their ear-coverts.
Coues’s Arctic Redpoll, adult female, Nothern Finland, March, 2015.
Adult (male and female)
An adult bird moults all its feathers after the breeding season and has, among other things, fresh tertials and fresh greater coverts in Autumn, Winter and Spring. The tertials are the inner-most secondaries and they are generally highly visible in the field. You can recognize the fresh tertials and greater coverts by the lack of wear and by the presence of a white (or pale) fringe. Later in the breeding season (June), the tertials and greater coverts have more wear, so this feature of ageing can’t be used then. This feature is especially useful for the period of time when the feathers of the birds are still fresh, so later in the year this feature is less useful because the feathers of adults birds also show traces of wear.
Hornemann’s Arctic Redpoll, adult, Greenland, March, 2013. Fresh tertials and fresh greater coverts with white fringing without feather wear.
Coues’s Arctic Redpoll, adult male, Alaska, June, 2015. Tertials and greater coverts with wear. In June the feature of the fresh tertials from adult redpolls doesn’t count anymore.
When we talk about adult redpolls, the tips of the tail feathers are often rounder after the moult (after the breeding season) than those of immatures birds. This is because the tail feathers of the young birds are fully grown in the nest and don’t moult in Autumn; so the tail feathers of young birds are older, have more wear and are therefore more pointed. Adult birds just get a new tail after the breeding season. In Spring the tail of an adult bird isn't as old, fresher and has less wear and a rounder shape than a second calendar year bird.
Please note: later in the year this feature is less useful. I find it difficult to recognize it in the field and it doesn’t always apply as adult birds can have pointed tail feathers too. So this particular feature isn’t that useful!
Hornemann’s Arctic Redpoll, adult, Greenland, March, 2013. Round tail feathers.
Mealy Redpoll, adult male, Scheveningen, The Netherlands, January 2006. Round tail feathers.
Coues’s Arctic Redpoll, first year (second calendar), Northern Finland, March, 2015. Pointed tail feathers.
Let’s make it a bit more difficult. First year birds (both male and female) look almost like an adult female. A good indication are the fresh (from adults) or worn (first year) tertials and greater coverts in Autumn, Winter and Spring. But from late Spring this feature doesn’t work anymore because of the feather wear of adult birds. A first year male doesn’t have the pink/red tints of an adult man, but you've probably figured out that already.
Hornemann’s Arctic Redpoll, first year (second calendar), Greenland, March, 2013. Worn tertials without white fringing.
Mealy Redpoll, first year (second calendar), Northern Finland, March, 2015. Worn tertials with a minimal pale fringe.
Mealy Redpoll, first year (first calendar), The Netherlands, October, 2016. Worn tertials with a minimal pale fringe.
Hornemann’s Arctic Redpolls, Greenland, October, 2017. First calendar year, A) pointed tail feathers and B) worn tertials with a minimal pale fringe. Adult, C) round tail feathers and D) fresh tertials with white fringing without feather wear.
Young birds which have just left the nest do not have the red forecrown. As Autumn progresses the red forecrown will become present. These young birds moult their feathers, except for the tail and a part of their wings in their first Autumn.
Coues’s Arctic Redpoll, juvenile, Alaska, June, 2015. Pay attention to the missing red forecrown.
Bird keepers regularly ask me the question how to recognize whether a redpoll is a male or a female. I have two pieces of advice:
• Observe the bird itself: a male will sing later in Winter and during Spring, he will also try to seduce a female and feed her.
• You can easily pluck off some breast feathers from the bird. Give the bird water mixed with carotene for two or three days and within a few weeks there will be new feathers. When the bird is a male, the new feathers will contain red/pink tints. This will not happen if it’s a female.
Mealy Redpoll, adult male, Rotterdam, the Netherlands, September, 2015. Isabel mutation.